Practical temperature guides, thermometer comparisons and buying advice.
Comparisons

Nest 3rd Gen vs ecobee3: Which Smart Thermostat Is Better?

Nest Learning Thermostat (3rd gen) vs ecobee3: room sensors, C-wire needs, HVAC compatibility, smart home support and current update status, from Google and ecobee specs.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product links in this article may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Read our affiliate disclosure

Hand adjusting a modern smart thermostat
Photo via Pexels

Editor’s note: This comparison replaces our earlier Nest 3 vs ecobee3 article, which is no longer available. It was rewritten in November 2026 from Google’s technical specifications for the Nest Learning Thermostat (3rd gen) and ecobee’s own product page for the ecobee3 (linked at the end). Both have been succeeded by newer models: Google launched the Nest Learning Thermostat (4th gen) in 2024, and ecobee replaced the ecobee3 with later models. This guide is most useful if you own one, are buying used, or are deciding whether to upgrade. We haven’t tested these thermostats ourselves.

Quick answer

  • Room sensing is the biggest difference. The ecobee3 came with a wireless room sensor in the box. The Nest 3rd gen measures at the thermostat, but works with Google’s Nest Temperature Sensor, sold separately.
  • Wiring: Google says the Nest 3rd gen is designed to work without a C wire in many homes, though some need one or a Nest Power Connector. The ecobee3 needs a C wire or ecobee’s Power Extender Kit.
  • Compatibility: the Nest 3rd gen lists 3 heating and 2 cooling stages; the ecobee3 lists 2H/2C conventional and 4H/2C heat pump, plus humidifier, dehumidifier and ventilator support.
  • Support: Google says the 3rd gen continues to receive updates and support in the Nest and Home apps. Its end-of-support announcement covered only the 1st and 2nd gen.
  • Choose the ecobee3 for multi-room comfort and broad accessory control. Choose the Nest 3rd gen for its premium design, C-wire flexibility and Google Home integration.

The Nest Learning Thermostat (3rd gen) and the ecobee3 were two of the best-known smart thermostats of the mid-2010s. They take different approaches: Nest is a round, minimalist dial that’s designed to learn from your adjustments, while ecobee built its system around remote room sensors. Here’s how they compare, using each manufacturer’s published specifications.

Nest 3rd gen vs ecobee3 at a glance

Specification Nest Learning Thermostat (3rd gen) ecobee3
Display 2.08″ round, 24-bit color LCD, 480 × 480 (229 ppi) 3.5″ full-color LCD touchscreen, 320 × 480
Controls Rotating ring (Google lists a magnetic sensor for ring position) Touchscreen
Room sensors Nest Temperature Sensor compatible (sold separately) 1 room sensor included; more sold separately
Sensors on the thermostat Temperature, humidity, proximity, motion, ambient light Not listed on ecobee’s spec page; humidity sensitivity listed as ±5% RH
Heating / cooling stages Heat 1–3 stages; cool 1–2 stages; heat pump with aux and emergency heat Conventional 2H/2C; heat pump 4H/2C
Accessories Humidifier or dehumidifier; 1–3 fan speeds (with limits, see below) Humidifier, dehumidifier, ventilator, HRV/ERV
Power 20–30 VAC; designed to work without a C wire in many homes, but a C wire or Nest Power Connector is required in some cases; built-in rechargeable battery 24 VAC via C wire, or the Power Extender Kit
Wireless Wi-Fi 802.11 a/b/g/n (2.4 and 5 GHz), 802.15.4, Bluetooth Low Energy Wi-Fi 802.11 b/g/n (2.4 GHz)
Set-point range Not listed on Google’s spec page 44–92°F (7–33°C)
Temperature accuracy Not listed on Google’s spec page ±0.9°F (±0.5°C)
Smart home Nest and Google Home apps; Google Assistant ecobee app; Apple HomeKit, Samsung SmartThings, IFTTT and others
Size 3.3″ diameter, 1.21″ deep (assembled) 3.93 × 3.93 × 0.86 in
Warranty Not listed on Google’s spec page 3 years

Nest figures are from Google’s Nest thermostat technical specifications. ecobee figures are from ecobee’s ecobee3 product page while it was on sale.

Room sensors and comfort

Ordinary thermostats only know the temperature where they’re mounted, often a hallway. ecobee’s answer was the room sensor: the ecobee3 shipped with one wireless sensor that reports temperature and occupancy, so the thermostat can focus on the rooms you’re actually using. Extra sensors were sold separately.

The Nest 3rd gen relies on its own built-in sensors, including proximity and motion sensors that help it tell whether anyone is home. If you want readings from another room, Google says both generations of the Nest Temperature Sensor work with the 3rd gen Learning Thermostat.

Installation and wiring

The Nest 3rd gen has a built-in rechargeable battery and, according to Google, is designed to work even if your home doesn’t have a C (common) wire. Google adds that some systems still need a C wire or its Nest Power Connector. The ecobee3 needs a C wire for 24 V power, or ecobee’s Power Extender Kit, which was included in the box.

Google also notes some limits on the 3rd gen: only one of the HUM, DEHUM, E, W3 or G3 connections can be used at once, and it supports either multiple fan speeds or multiple heating and cooling stages, not both. Google strongly recommends professional installation for dual-fuel systems, whole-home humidifiers or dehumidifiers, and multi-speed fans. The ecobee3 lists dual fuel among its compatible systems, plus humidifier, dehumidifier and ventilator control.

For more on wiring and system types, see our thermostat buying guide.

Nest Learning Thermostat (3rd gen)

Pros

  • High-resolution round display and premium finishes
  • Often works without a C wire
  • Proximity and motion sensing built in
  • Dual-band Wi-Fi (2.4 and 5 GHz)
  • Still receiving updates, per Google

Cons

  • No room sensor included
  • Limits on combining accessories and stages
  • No Apple HomeKit listed by Google

Check Price on Amazon

ecobee3

Pros

  • Room sensor included
  • Large touchscreen
  • Broad accessory support, including ventilators and HRV/ERV
  • Heat pump systems up to 4H/2C
  • Apple HomeKit support

Cons

  • Needs a C wire or the Power Extender Kit
  • 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi only
  • Discontinued; buying used means no new warranty

Check Price on Amazon

Which should you choose?

Choose the Nest 3rd gen if…

  • You don’t have a C wire and want to avoid adding one.
  • You use Google Home and Google Assistant.
  • You want a thermostat that doubles as a design piece.

Choose the ecobee3 if…

  • Some rooms are always hotter or colder than the thermostat location.
  • You control a ventilator, HRV/ERV or a multi-stage heat pump.
  • You use Apple HomeKit.

Buying new? Both companies now sell newer models. Compare current options in our ecobee vs Nest guide, and see our ecobee3 vs ecobee4 comparison for ecobee’s next generation.

Bottom line

The ecobee3 is the better pick for whole-home comfort, thanks to its included room sensor and wide accessory support. The Nest Learning Thermostat (3rd gen) is easier to fit in homes without a C wire, has a sharper display and dual-band Wi-Fi, and, according to Google, still receives updates. If you’re buying today, consider the newer generations from each brand.

FAQ

Is the Nest 3rd gen still supported?

Yes. In its announcement ending support for the 1st and 2nd gen Nest Learning Thermostats from October 25, 2025, Google said the 3rd gen will continue to receive updates and support in the Nest and Home apps.

Does the Nest 3rd gen need a C wire?

Google says it’s designed to work even without a C wire, but some systems require a C wire or the Nest Power Connector.

Does the ecobee3 come with a room sensor?

Yes. According to ecobee, one room sensor with a detachable stand was included in the box.

Can the Nest 3rd gen use remote sensors?

Yes. Google says both generations of the Nest Temperature Sensor are compatible with the Nest Learning Thermostat (3rd gen), sold separately.

Which works with Apple HomeKit?

ecobee lists Apple HomeKit support for the ecobee3. Google’s specifications for the Nest 3rd gen don’t list HomeKit.

Sources: Google, Nest thermostat technical specifications; Google, Learn about the Nest Temperature Sensor; Google Home & Nest Community, Support changes to our earliest generation Nest Learning Thermostats; ecobee3 product page and technical specs (archived 2017). Checked November 2026.