Editor’s note: Originally published December 2020. Reviewed and updated November 2026. Some models mentioned here may have been updated or discontinued since; check current availability and specifications before buying.
Quick answer
- Best programmable (buttons): Orbit 83521 Clear Comfort — 7-day, four-period programming, Energy Star preset schedule and a large backlit display.
- Best touchscreen: Honeywell RTH8500D — 7-day touchscreen programming, Smart Response Technology and Vacation Hold; needs a C wire.
- Best non-programmable: Honeywell TH3110D1008 Pro — simple up/down control, listed accuracy within 1 degree and a 5-year limited warranty when professionally installed.
- The Orbit and the RTH8500D are not compatible with electric baseboard heat, so check your system first.
You don’t need a smart thermostat to get reliable temperature control. For under $50 you can buy a 7-day programmable thermostat, a basic touchscreen model or a simple non-programmable unit that just holds the temperature you set. Prices change, so check current prices before buying.
Below are three budget thermostats, one for each style, based on the features and specifications their manufacturers list. Before buying any thermostat, confirm it is compatible with your heating and cooling system; our thermostat buying guide explains what to check.
Best programmable thermostat under $50
Orbit 83521 Clear Comfort Programmable Thermostat
The Orbit 83521 Clear Comfort is a programmable thermostat built around a large, easy-to-read display with blue backlighting and a glass faceplate. The temperature is shown in a large font that you can read from across the room.
It uses fingertip up/down buttons and simple switches rather than a touchscreen, which some people find easier to use. You can program each day separately with up to four periods per day, and a copy feature lets you duplicate a day’s schedule and change only what you need.
It comes preloaded with Energy Star recommended settings, which Orbit says can save up to 33% on your energy bill. Early Start mode begins heating or cooling ahead of time so the room reaches your set temperature on schedule, and permanent or temporary hold lets you override the program when you want.
Listed specifications
- 7-day programming with four periods per day; copy-day feature
- Preloaded Energy Star recommended settings
- Early Start mode; permanent and temporary hold
- Backlit LCD display
- Listed accuracy within 1 degree
- Compatible with two-wire hot water systems, central heating and cooling, millivolt systems and heat pumps without auxiliary/backup heat
- 1-year warranty
Pros
- Flexible 7-day, four-period programming with copy feature
- Simple buttons and switches instead of a touchscreen
- Energy-saving preset schedule out of the box
- Large, clear backlit display
Cons
- Not compatible with baseboard heaters, multi-stage heating or cooling, or three-wire hydronic systems
- No on-screen summary of your program, which can make programming confusing
- Some people find installation tricky
- Not a touchscreen
Best touchscreen thermostat under $50
Honeywell RTH8500D 7-Day Touchscreen Programmable Thermostat
The Honeywell RTH8500D offers a backlit touchscreen and 7-day programming at a budget-friendly price. You can set a different schedule for each day, so the system runs less while you’re at work and cools things down at night if you like to sleep cold.
Honeywell’s Smart Response Technology continuously adjusts pre-heating and cooling so the temperature is right at your programmed times, and the thermostat switches between heating and cooling automatically. Vacation Hold pauses the program while you’re away and resumes it when you return.
Other conveniences include a green backlight that is easy on night vision, a filter change reminder, automatic daylight saving time adjustment, and memory that keeps your settings, time and date through a power outage. It needs a C wire and is compatible with most heating, cooling and heat pump systems. If you want Wi-Fi control, you’ll need to spend more; see our Honeywell RTH6580WF review for a Wi-Fi option.
Listed specifications
- 7-day programmable touchscreen with green backlight
- Smart Response Technology; automatic heat/cool changeover
- Vacation Hold; filter change reminder; automatic daylight saving adjustment
- Keeps settings, time and date through power outages
- Compatible with heating, cooling and heat pump systems (C wire required)
- Certified energy savings
- 1-year warranty
Pros
- Touchscreen with 7-day programming at a budget price
- Smart Response Technology pre-heats and pre-cools to hit your schedule
- Automatic heat/cool changeover and Vacation Hold
- Retains settings after a power outage
Cons
- Not compatible with electric baseboard heat
- Requires a C wire
- Furnace may cycle on and off too frequently
- The unit stops working if the battery dies
- Touchscreen could be more sensitive
Best non-programmable thermostat under $50
Honeywell TH3110D1008 Pro Non-Programmable Digital Thermostat
If programmable and smart thermostats feel like more trouble than they’re worth, the Honeywell TH3110D1008 Pro simply keeps the temperature where you set it. There is no scheduling and no Wi-Fi: use the up and down buttons, choose fan On or Auto, select heat or cool, and you’re done.
The display shows both the room temperature and your setting, and Honeywell lists it as accurate to within one degree. Its backlight turns on only when you press a button, so it stays discreet but can be hard to find in the dark. It does not switch between heating and cooling automatically, which may be inconvenient in climates with big daily temperature swings.
It works with a wide range of systems, and the 5-year limited warranty applies when it is professionally installed.
Listed specifications
- Non-programmable; up/down temperature buttons; fan On/Auto
- Listed accuracy within 1 degree
- Works with gas, oil or electric heat with air conditioning, furnaces, heat pumps, steam, gravity, heat-only and cool-only systems
- Backlit display (on button press)
- 5-year limited warranty if professionally installed
Pros
- Extremely simple to use
- Listed accuracy within one degree
- Works with many system types
- Long warranty for a budget thermostat
Cons
- Backlight only comes on when pressed, so it is hard to find in the dark
- No automatic switching between heating and cooling
- Batteries can run down quickly depending on use
- Warranty requires professional installation
Which budget thermostat should you choose?
- Orbit 83521 if you want programming with physical buttons and an energy-saving schedule ready to go.
- Honeywell RTH8500D if you prefer a touchscreen, automatic heat/cool changeover and vacation mode, and you have a C wire.
- Honeywell TH3110D1008 if you’re home most of the time and just want a reliable set-and-leave thermostat.
For more Honeywell options, see our Honeywell thermostat buying guide. If you’re ready to spend more for learning features, our Nest thermostat reviews cover a smart alternative.
Bottom line
A thermostat under $50 can still give you solid control. Pick programmable if you want to save energy on a schedule, touchscreen if you want a more modern interface, and non-programmable if you want simplicity. Whatever you choose, check compatibility with your system first, especially if you have baseboard heat or a multi-stage system.
FAQ
Do these thermostats work with electric baseboard heat?
No. The Orbit 83521 and Honeywell RTH8500D are listed as not compatible with baseboard heat, and the TH3110D1008 is not listed for it either.
Does the Honeywell RTH8500D need a C wire?
Yes. It is compatible with most heating, cooling and heat pump systems as long as a C wire is present.
Can a budget thermostat save energy?
Programmable models can. Orbit says its preloaded Energy Star settings can save up to 33% on your energy bill, though actual savings depend on your home and how you use it.